YNOT
  • Home
  • Industry News
    • Adult Business News
    • Adult Novelty News
    • YNOT Magazine
    • EU News
    • Opinions
    • Picture Galleries
  • PR Wire
    • Adult Company News
    • Adult Retail News
    • Adult Talent News
    • Adult Videos News
  • Podcasts
  • Industry Guides
    • Adult Affiliate Guide
    • Affiliate Marketing for Beginners
    • Top Adult Traffic Networks
    • Top Adult PR Agents
    • Funding an Adult Business
  • Business Directory
    • View Categories
    • View Listings
    • Submit Listing
  • Newsletters
  • Industry Events
    • Events Calendar
    • YNOT Cam Awards | Hollywood
    • YNOT Awards | Prague
    • YNOT Cammunity
    • YNOT Summit
    • YNOT Reunion
  • Login with YNOT ID

Arkansas Hops on Porn-Blocking Bandwagon; Will it Stay There?

Posted On 17 Dec 2018
By : GeneZorkin

ArkansasLITTLE ROCK, Ark. – Like numerous other state legislatures before it, the Arkansas General Assembly is now considering a bill called the “Human Trafficking and Child Exploitation Prevention Act” (“HTCEPA”).

Seeing as how virtually identical legislation has been considered, only to later be shelved, in states like Georgia, Virginia, Rhode Island and Alabama, just to name a handful, it seems fair to ask: Will Arkansas eventually abandon its consideration of this bill, too?

I believe the state will at some point, as quietly as possible, let this version of the HTCEPA die in committee, as other state legislatures before them have done.

In part, I believe this because – as I’ve noted before – the person who wrote this bill and has gone around the country promoting it to various legislatures appears to be a crazy person. This was certainly a factor in Rhode Island’s decision to drop its consideration of the HTCEPA; back in March, a State Senator there said the bill was withdrawn due to its “dubious origins.”

More importantly, I think just about any attorney familiar with First Amendment jurisprudence will tell you the HTCEPA is unlikely to survive court scrutiny, if it were to become law, regardless of which state’s version you were to ask them about.

The draft legislation of the HTCEPA has been virtually identical in each state – and the Arkansas version suffers from the same obvious problems which have plagued the bills briefly considered elsewhere. As has been the case in other states, the Arkansas version of the legislation, HB 1032, would establish a “Prohibition against commercial sale or distribution of (a) device that may be used to access obscene material.”

Given that the question of whether any given work is legally “obscene” is something determined at trial, how can a device be secured against accessing such materials, before they’ve been adjudicated obscene?

Under Arkansas law, “obscene material” has a statutory definition which essentially mirrors the Miller Test applied in obscenity trials. That definition states obscene material means material that “Depicts or describes in a patently offensive manner sadomasochistic abuse, sexual conduct, or hard-core sexual conduct… (that) taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest of the average person, applying contemporary statewide standards; and taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value.”

How can an automated content filter, regardless of the device on which it is installed, possibly make such a determination? Put simply, it can’t.

As attorney Larry Walters noted to YNOT in discussing the iteration of the HTCEPA under consideration in Alabama earlier this year, “there are so many problems with these iterations of (the HTCEPA), it’s hard to know where to start.”

“The First Amendment violations and chilling effects on protected speech are massive,” Walters said. “The inability to accurately determine what content actually needs to be blocked, and the herculean effort required to identify every piece of content on the internet that should be included in the filter, imposes an intolerable burden on the First Amendment. Naturally, there will be a tendency to over-censor, which creates the chilling effect.”

The problems with the HTCEPA wouldn’t be contained within the borders of any state which passes it, either.

“The potential applicability to individual sellers, who may be selling to buyers in other states, creates dormant commerce clause problems, because of the substantial burden on interstate commerce,” Walters said.

Will Arkansas buck history – and, quite likely, the advice of its own legislative counsel – and pass the HTCEPA where other states have declined to do so?

I’d like to think the answer is no, but it’s hard to predict such things. After all, if Arkansas does pass the HTCEPA, it’s not like it would be the first time the state’s legislature has approved a speech-restricting bill that was doomed to fall apart under court scrutiny.

About the Author
Gene Zorkin has been covering legal and political issues for various adult publications (and under a variety of different pen names) since 2002.
  • google-share
Previous Story

Segpay Donating Payment Services to FSC

Next Story

Plant Seeds on Nutaku.net’s ‘Booty Farm’

Related Posts

Are We CERTAIN ‘Veggie Tales’ Isn’t Harmful to Minors?

Are We CERTAIN ‘Veggie Tales’ Isn’t Harmful to Minors?

Posted On 01 Jul 2025
, By Ben Suroeste
Free Speech Coalition

FSC Decries Supreme Court’s “Radical Departure from Precedent”

Posted On 30 Jun 2025
, By GeneZorkin
Justices of the Supreme Court

Supreme Court Upholds Texas Age-Verification Law

Posted On 27 Jun 2025
, By GeneZorkin

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Sponsor

YNOT Shoot Me

YNOTShootMe.com has exclusive pics from adult industry business events. Check it out!

YNOT Directory

  • RIVCash
    Live Cam Affiliate Programs
  • Video Secrets
    Live Cam Affiliate Programs
  • West Coast Leather
    Novelty & Lingerie Manufacturers
  • Premiere Listing

    TrafficStars

    More Details

RECENT

POPULAR

COMMENTS

Jewell Marceau Visits Matt Slayer's 'And Now We Drink' Podcast

Posted On 08 Jul 2025

Ria Bentley and Silas Stone Deliver Scorching Hot New Scene

Posted On 08 Jul 2025

It’s The Occult vs. Taking Care of Business at Evolved Fights Lez

Posted On 08 Jul 2025

Vanessa, Meet Vivid

Posted On 29 Sep 2014
Laila Mickelwaite and Exodus Cry

Laila Mickelwaite, Exodus Cry and their Crusade Against Porn

Posted On 03 May 2021

Sex Toy Collective Dildo Sculptor

Posted On 19 Mar 2019

Find a good sex toy is now a problem,...

Posted On 18 Mar 2024

Thanks to the variety of sex toys, I can...

Posted On 02 Feb 2024

I understand the concerns about...

Posted On 05 Jan 2024

Sponsor

Sitemap
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy Policy