AUSTIN, Texas – A little over three years ago, the Free Speech Coalition filed a lawsuit against the state of Texas over the age-verification requirements established when HB 1181 was signed into law.
While the great and wise U.S. Supreme Court ultimately upheld the law’s age verification components, because “fuck you we’re turning decades of First Amendment precedent on its head just because we can” (OK, I’ll concede this might not be an entirely accurate direct quote, as I’m working from memory here) what wasn’t before the court at the time was the question of whether the law’s ‘warning label’ requirements were constitutional, because the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals had left intact the portion of the lower court’s ruling with respect to the warning labels.
So now, lawyers for us godless heathens here in Online Smutville find themselves back in a Texas courtroom, asking the court to award summary judgment on the warning labels question.
While I’m no lawyer (hell, I haven’t even pretended to be one to shake someone down for at least six weeks!), I’m still going to quote from the court documents, because it makes me feel less dumb when my pulled-from-my-ass opinions mesh nicely with arguments made by smarter, more sophisticated and less stoned people.
“Both this Court and the Fifth Circuit concluded, on the preliminary injunction record, that the health warnings and notice provisions in Texas H.B 1181 are unconstitutional under the First Amendment,” FSC noted in its motion. “In the months since remand, further factual development has only reinforced the reasoning of those decisions. Texas has admitted that the statements in the health warnings were never confirmed by the Texas Health and Services Commission, nor apparently by any regulatory body. Texas has admitted that it neither attempted a government-funded public information campaign nor established that such a campaign would be ineffective. Its own experts have admitted that if the age-verification requirements of the law work as intended, no minor will ever read the warnings and notices in the first place. And the language still exceeds the average child’s reading level and will do nothing to deter minors who managed to elude the age-verification restrictions.”
All that stuff goes directly to legal arguments FSC makes in its motion, some of which I could probably even understand if I stopped huffing paint for a couple days – but that’s a sacrifice I’m just not willing to make.
So, instead of trying to analyze the FSC’s argument or the response from Texas, I want to reframe this as a non-legal question: When a government is requiring people to lie, is that something we can and should accept?
Worse still, with these labels, the Texas government isn’t just requiring people who run adult websites to lie, it is requiring us to lie about things its own government agencies have determined.
As FSC noted in its motion, among other things the Texas law requires sites to publish, in 14-point font or larger, statements like:
“TEXAS HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WARNING: Pornography is potentially biologically addictive, is proven to harm human brain development, desensitizes brain reward circuits, increases conditioned responses, and weakens brain function.”
There are many problems with that statement, but the first and most fundamental is that the Texas Department of Health and Human Services has determined no such thing.
Sure, the label doesn’t outright claim the Texas HHS has made such a determination, but it sure seems to imply such when you make people render an all-caps screamer like “TEXAS HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WARNING” above a series of warnings.
This fact wasn’t lost on US District Court Judge David Ezra, the judge who issued the injunction – and the same poor bastard who now must read these most recent filings and hear arguments in a case I’m sure he’d prefer to simply disappear.
As Ezra observed in originally issuing his injunction in 2023, “Texas Health and Human Services Commission has not made these findings or announcements.”
“The government is forcing commercial sites to speak and broadcast a proposition that they disagree with,” Ezra added. “The Supreme Court has ‘held time and again that freedom of speech includes both the right to speak freely and the right to refrain from speaking at all.’… Even if, as the defendant argues, the law compels only commercial speech, it does not pass constitutional muster.”
Again, I’m no lawyer – but my money is on Judge Ezra’s take on this question. After all, if it’s legal for the government to not only force people to make statements with which they disagree, but to compel them to say things that are objectively untrue as well, the First Amendment might as well be repurposed as toilet paper… which, on the bright side, I suppose we could then to use to festoon Ken Paxton’s house, so at least some good would come of all this.
Image by Brett Jordan of Pexels







