YNOT
  • Home
  • Industry News
    • Adult Business News
    • Adult Novelty News
    • YNOT Magazine
    • EU News
    • Opinions
    • Picture Galleries
  • PR Wire
    • Adult Company News
    • Adult Retail News
    • Adult Talent News
    • Adult Videos News
  • Podcasts
  • Industry Guides
    • Adult Affiliate Guide
    • Affiliate Marketing for Beginners
    • Top Adult Traffic Networks
    • Top Adult PR Agents
    • Funding an Adult Business
  • Business Directory
    • View Categories
    • View Listings
    • Submit Listing
  • Newsletters
  • Industry Events
    • Events Calendar
    • YNOT Cam Awards | Hollywood
    • YNOT Awards | Prague
    • YNOT Cammunity
    • YNOT Summit
    • YNOT Reunion
  • Login with YNOT ID

Facebook Draws Arbitrary Line Around ‘Porn’

Posted On 22 May 2017
By : GeneZorkin

From a Facebook policy perspective, is the Peter Paul Rubens "The Rape of Europa" more acceptable than the Francisco de Goya rendition, or vice versa?MENLO PARK, Calif. – The technologies behind social media platforms may be modern, but the conundrum predates the printing press: When it comes to depictions of sexuality, where is the line drawn between “pornography” and “art”?

Among the intriguing details that have emerged from an internal policy document allegedly leaked from Facebook, the one that grabbed my attention is an odd distinction the company’s policies make between “handmade sexual activity” and “digital sexual activity.”

“We allow nudity when it is depicted in art like paintings, sculptures and drawings,” the policy document states. “We do not allow digitally created nudity or sexual activity. We drew this line so that we could remove a lot of very sexual digital nudity, but it also covers an increasing amount of non-sexual digitally made art. The current line is also difficult to enforce because it is hard to differentiate between handmade art and digitally made depictions.”

So, in other words, if I hand-carve a sculpture of a naked woman, Facebook should have no issue with my work, but if I post a photoshopped image in which I have manipulated a digital photo of a naked woman to look like a sculpture, this image is liable to be pulled down?

Alternatively, maybe what the policy means is I may post as many images of my nude statue work as I can sculpt, so long as I don’t also post a photograph of the nude models whose poses serve as the basis of my work?

Either way, I’m betting Michelangelo is looking up at us from hell and counting his lucky stars he lived before the age of social media, in which he may have been subjected to an account cancellation if someone were to decide David depicts a minor.

The good news is this isn’t about private-sector censorship — not as Facebook sees things, at least.

“Keeping people on Facebook safe is the most important thing we do,” Monika Bickert, head of global policy management at Facebook, told CNET. “We work hard to make Facebook as safe as possible while enabling free speech.”

To be fair, I think Bickert was referring more to instances of revenge porn, “sextortion” and threats of sexual violence than to the need to shield its users from the dangers of Renaissance sculpture. Still, there must be something terribly threatening about certain works of art, considering the policy guidelines include specific instructions to remove images of “The Rape of Europa” and “The Abduction of the Sabine Women” when such are posted.

This raises another question for me, because not all depictions of the rape of Europa are created equal. For example, from a Facebook policy perspective, is the Peter Paul Rubens version more acceptable than the Francisco de Goya rendition, or vice versa?

Beyond the difficulty of making qualitative distinctions between Romantic and Baroque interpretations of Classical mythological stories, is the concern driving Facebook to remove these works based on their titles, or have we become so sensitive to the possibility of fostering “rape culture” that any reference to or depiction of rape, even fictitious and mythological, is now strictly verboten?

As has been quite forcefully demonstrated of late, Facebook is also confronting a dilemma when it comes to depictions of non-sexual violence. Will part of the company’s response to concerns about such violence include compulsory take-downs of Guernica, or would they limit their removals to more realistic works, like Anne-Louis Girodet’s “Revolt of Cairo”?

Facebook’s content policies are shaping up to be a challenge with no solution, it seems to me, and we haven’t even reached the question of whether there’s a Facebook policy distinction to be made between ISIS beheading videos and the dismantling of a certain stubborn Black Knight.

 

Image: “The Rape of Europa,” Peter Paul Rubens, 1628-29.

 

About the Author
Gene Zorkin has been covering legal and political issues for various adult publications (and under a variety of different pen names) since 2002.
  • google-share
Previous Story

OVO Lifestyle Toys Adds Online Promo Assets Library

Next Story

Disgraced Prenda Perp John Steele Disbarred (Finally)

Related Posts

Erika Lust Decries Deletion of Her Instagram Account

Erika Lust Decries Deletion of Her Instagram Account

Posted On 09 Apr 2025
, By GeneZorkin
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals dismisses more counts in NCOSE lawsuit against Twitter

Appeals Court Partly Reverses, Remands NCOSE-Backed Lawsuit Targeting Twitter

Posted On 04 May 2023
, By GeneZorkin
Does banning adult content on social media prevent CSAM?

Does Banning Adult Content on Social Media Sites Prevent CSAM?

Posted On 02 May 2023
, By Michael McGrady

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Sponsor

YNOT Shoot Me

YNOTShootMe.com has exclusive pics from adult industry business events. Check it out!

YNOT Directory

  • delevit – remove your leaked content
    Other Professional Services
  • Pair Networks
    Hosting & Technical Services
  • WordPress Tube Theme
    Website Scripts
  • Premiere Listing

    imaXcash — Dating Affiliate Network

    More Details

RECENT

POPULAR

COMMENTS

It’s Lucifer vs The Lizard at Evolved Fights

Posted On 17 Jun 2025

Smoking Hot Spinner Nicole Nichols Makes Nookies Debut

Posted On 17 Jun 2025

Trans Star Tori Easton Kicks Off June Pride Month

Posted On 17 Jun 2025

Vanessa, Meet Vivid

Posted On 29 Sep 2014
Laila Mickelwaite and Exodus Cry

Laila Mickelwaite, Exodus Cry and their Crusade Against Porn

Posted On 03 May 2021

Sex Toy Collective Dildo Sculptor

Posted On 19 Mar 2019

Find a good sex toy is now a problem,...

Posted On 18 Mar 2024

Thanks to the variety of sex toys, I can...

Posted On 02 Feb 2024

I understand the concerns about...

Posted On 05 Jan 2024

Sponsor

Sitemap
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy Policy