YNOT
  • Home
  • Industry News
    • Adult Business News
    • Adult Novelty News
    • YNOT Magazine
    • EU News
    • Opinions
    • Picture Galleries
  • PR Wire
    • Adult Company News
    • Adult Retail News
    • Adult Talent News
    • Adult Videos News
  • Podcasts
  • Industry Guides
    • Adult Affiliate Guide
    • Affiliate Marketing for Beginners
    • Top Adult Traffic Networks
    • Top Adult PR Agents
    • Funding an Adult Business
  • Business Directory
    • View Categories
    • View Listings
    • Submit Listing
  • Newsletters
  • Industry Events
    • Events Calendar
    • YNOT Cam Awards | Hollywood
    • YNOT Awards | Prague
    • YNOT Cammunity
    • YNOT Summit
    • YNOT Reunion
  • Login with YNOT ID

MetArt Wins Appeal Over Jurisdiction in Porn.com Copyright Infringement Case

Posted On 27 Aug 2019
By : RhettPardon

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth CircuitSAN FRANCISCO — Jason Tucker, who runs a leading anti-piracy management and enforcement company, believes that a recent federal court of appeals ruling offers a warning shot to copyright infringers trying to avoid U.S. courts: They can run but they can’t hide.

A three-judge panel with the 9th U.S. Court of Appeals earlier this month held that a lower court erred in finding a lack of personal jurisdiction with Porn.com or any of the other foreign entities and individuals named as defendants in a suit waged by Santa Monica, Calif.-based MetArt Network.

“This ruling will serve as a standard to defining what is necessary to establish jurisdiction,” said Tucker, president of Battleship Stance and an industry veteran who is serving as plaintiff’s consultant for MetArt, which filed the infringement suit against Porn.com, based in Seychelles; MXN Ltd., based in Barbados; and Netmedia Services Inc., based in Canada.

Tucker told YNOT that the recent ruling “affirmatively establishes that pirates located outside the U.S. will be held accountable here when taking advantage of the U.S. market.”

“In this case MetArt is doing what is necessary to protect its library,” Tucker said. “If site operators spent as much time and money to try and settle claims as they do trying to avoid U.S. court, these cases would close out sooner and probably be a lot cheaper.

In the lower court ruling last year, U.S. District Judge David G. Campbell found that MetArt had no personal jurisdiction over Porn.com.

MetArt, which filed the suit three years ago, alleged that scraped content was found on four Porn.com websites. Porn.com, in response, claimed that the poached videos were uploaded by third-party users.

Campbell earlier granted the defendants’ motions to dismiss and terminated the case on the issue of personal jurisdiction.

The 9th Circuit, however, provided another lawsuit lifeline for MetArt by reversing Campbell’s decision, finding that Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(k)(2), the federal long-arm statute, authorizes a district court’s exercise of personal jurisdiction over a defendant if (1) the claim arises under federal law; (2) the defendant is not subject to jurisdiction of any state court of general jurisdiction; and (3) exercising jurisdiction comports with due process.

Porn.com defendants acknowledged that the first two criteria were met.

So was the third, the 9th Circuit said, because it is alleged that there were intentional acts of copyright infringement aimed at the U.S. and causing harm here.

“[MetArt] alleges that [Porn.com] unauthorized display of its copyrighted videos, which [MetArt] makes available for a fee, resulted in lost profits and reputational damage, and that the majority of its revenue is generated in the U.S.,” the 9th Circuit said in its decision. “Thus, as we must construe all facts in [MetArt’s] favor, it is not unreasonable to infer that the foreseeable economic harm alleged would have been suffered in the U.S.”

In its ruling arising out of forum-related activities, the 9th Circuit said that Porn.com “failed to show that exercising jurisdiction would be unreasonable and violate due process.”

“Personal jurisdiction is proper as to all owners or operators of Porn.com. On remand, the district court should determine which parties are owners or operators of Porn.com in addition to Cyberweb,” the court said in a footnote.

Tucker noted that the MetArt suit is similar in nature to another legal challenge waged by AMA Multimedia — the operator of more than 20 membership sites, including Passion-HD.com, Tiny4K.com and PornPros.com — against the same defendants.

“Porn.com has gone all in with the lawsuits they are facing,” Tucker said. “It is a risky play.”

Val Gurvits, an attorney with Boston Law Group representing Porn.com in the case, told YNOT that the 9th Circuit decision over jurisdiction wouldn’t be challenged.

“We feel that there is no reason to incur the additional expenses of an appeal,” Gurvits said. “We maintain that the present lawsuit is wholly frivolous, and we are confident that we will win this case on the merits.”

You can check out 9th Circuit oral arguments made in the case here.

About the Author
Rhett Pardon is a longtime business journalist who has focused on adult entertainment legal matters since the early 1990s. Got a tip? Send them his way (rhettpardon@gmail.com).
  • google-share
Previous Story

Luscious.net Security Hole Exposes 1 Million+ Users’ Data

Next Story

TROUBLEfilms Releases ‘Chelsea Submits’

Related Posts

Adult Industry Leaders Call for Immediate Action Against Eporner.com

Adult Industry Leaders Call for Immediate Action Against Eporner.com

Posted On 02 May 2024
, By GeneZorkin
MonteCahn

This Week’s Guest on Adult Site Broker Talk is Monte Cahn

Posted On 03 May 2023
, By Alyssa
If your law requires a million exemptions, maybe it's not a good law

If Your Law Needs Scores of Exemptions, Maybe Rethink the Law?

Posted On 21 Mar 2023
, By GeneZorkin

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Sponsor

YNOT Shoot Me

YNOTShootMe.com has exclusive pics from adult industry business events. Check it out!

YNOT Directory

  • CrakRevenue’s Dating Smartlink
    Dating Affiliate Programs
  • KoDDoS
    Website Hosting Services
  • The Dungeon Store
    Distributors & Manufacturers
  • Premiere Listing

    Live Studio

    More Details

RECENT

POPULAR

COMMENTS

Pineapple Support

Teasy Agency Joins Pineapple Support As Supporter-Level Sponsor

Posted On 13 Jun 2025

ChickPass Amateurs Newbie Corner Features MILF Jess B

Posted On 13 Jun 2025

Stephanie Love Scores Kink Queens Mag Cover & Feature

Posted On 13 Jun 2025

Vanessa, Meet Vivid

Posted On 29 Sep 2014
Laila Mickelwaite and Exodus Cry

Laila Mickelwaite, Exodus Cry and their Crusade Against Porn

Posted On 03 May 2021

Sex Toy Collective Dildo Sculptor

Posted On 19 Mar 2019

Find a good sex toy is now a problem,...

Posted On 18 Mar 2024

Thanks to the variety of sex toys, I can...

Posted On 02 Feb 2024

I understand the concerns about...

Posted On 05 Jan 2024

Sponsor

Sitemap
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy Policy